A company that owes you money is insolvent when it can’t pay its debts. A licensed insolvency practitioner then usually takes control of what it owns. Your unpaid invoice then becomes a claim in that process.
So will you get your money back? Usually only part of it. The law pays lenders holding security, the costs of the process, staff and some taxes before an ordinary supplier’s invoice. The payout to unsecured creditors, called a dividend, is often a few pence in the pound, and sometimes nothing.
That doesn’t mean the whole invoice is lost. A personal guarantee a director signed still stands. Goods you supplied on terms that keep them yours until you’re paid may still be yours to take back.
If you’ve paid the VAT on the invoice to HMRC, you can usually reclaim it once the debt is six months overdue. On a £12,000 invoice including 20% VAT, that’s £2,000 back. You repay part of it if a dividend arrives later.
It’s hard to judge how much more time and money to spend on a debt that may pay back little. Most of the steps that can improve your position work best in the first few weeks after the appointment.
Start by finding out whether the company is in a formal insolvency procedure or is only paying late, because the two need different action. A letter from a licensed insolvency practitioner, often headed Notice to Creditors, means a procedure has started.
When a creditor asks me whether it’s worth chasing, I want to know two things first. Did a director sign a personal guarantee for your account? And are any of your goods still on the customer’s premises?
Key Takeaways
- An unsecured trade creditor of an insolvent company is paid after the secured lender, the costs of the liquidation, staff and HMRC’s preferential taxes. The dividend is often a few pence in the pound.
- A proof of debt is your formal claim in a liquidation or administration. Lodging one costs nothing, and you can send it before you’re asked.
- Retention of title lets a supplier take back goods it still owns, if they can be identified. Contact the insolvency practitioner quickly, before the stock is sold or mixed with other stock.
- A personal guarantee from a director survives the company’s insolvency. You enforce it against the director personally, outside the liquidation queue.
- VAT bad debt relief lets you reclaim the VAT you paid on an unpaid invoice once it’s six months overdue and written off. You don’t have to wait for the liquidation to end.
How to Confirm the Company Is Actually Insolvent
When a creditor brings us an unpaid invoice, we ask for the company number first. That lets us check the company’s Companies House record and the Gazette before we talk about anything else.
You can run the same checks yourself. Search the debtor’s name on the London Gazette, where a liquidation, administration or receivership in England and Wales must be advertised. For Scottish or Northern Irish companies, check the Edinburgh or Belfast Gazette.
Then check Companies House using the company number, not just the trading name. The filing history shows documents such as the notice of a liquidator’s or administrator’s appointment. The company status also changes once a procedure is registered.
If nothing is gazetted and Companies House shows no insolvency filing, no formal process had started when you searched. It tells you nothing about whether the company can pay its bills. A clean record is no reason on its own to keep extending credit. Our guide on how to check recorded company insolvency proceedings explains what each result does and does not prove.
Until a procedure is on the record, you can still use the ordinary debt routes. They include a statutory demand for a debt of more than £750. That’s a formal written demand for payment, and if the company leaves it unpaid for 21 days, it can support a winding-up petition.
A debtor that mentions insolvency as a reason to delay payment hasn’t entered a procedure by saying so. A winding-up petition costs a £352 court fee, plus a £2,600 deposit towards the Official Receiver’s costs.
If your debtor is in a procedure, it helps to know your rights as a creditor before you’re asked to vote on anything.
Where Your Claim Sits Against an Insolvent Company
The Insolvency Act 1986 and the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016 fix the order in which creditors are paid. Once the company is in a procedure, pressing the directors doesn’t change your place in it.
Lenders with a fixed charge are paid first from the asset the charge covers. That’s usually a bank whose security covers the property or equipment.
Next come the costs of the insolvency, then the ordinary preferential creditors. These are employees, for wages owed in the four months before the insolvency up to £800 each, plus accrued holiday pay and certain pension contributions.
Since 1 December 2020, HMRC has been a secondary preferential creditor for VAT, PAYE, employees’ National Insurance and Construction Industry Scheme deductions. There’s no cap and no time limit on those amounts. Corporation Tax and employers’ National Insurance stay unsecured.
A floating charge is a lender’s security over assets that change, such as stock and debts owed to the company. Before the floating charge holder is paid, part of that money is set aside for unsecured creditors. This is the prescribed part, capped at £800,000 on charges created on or after 6 April 2020.
The prescribed part applies only to floating charges created on or after 15 September 2003. In a very small estate, the insolvency practitioner can decide not to pay it if the cost would be out of proportion.
After that, the floating charge holder is paid, then the ordinary unsecured creditors, which is where most trade suppliers sit. Shareholders come last and in an insolvent liquidation usually receive nothing. Our guide to preferential versus non-preferential creditor ranking sets out the full order.
For an unpaid supplier, the result is that unsecured trade creditors in a liquidation often receive a few pence in the pound, and sometimes nothing. That’s why a personal guarantee, retention of title and set-off often matter more to a supplier than the dividend.
Submitting a Proof of Debt to the Insolvent Company’s Liquidator
The proof of debt is your formal claim, made under Part 14 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016. The liquidator or administrator (the office-holder) will send you a form or point you to an online portal. You can lodge a proof without waiting to be asked.
Your proof must include the amount owed at the date of insolvency, how and when the debt arose, and any security you hold. Include any retention of title claim, and mention a personal guarantee if a director gave you one.
Attach the invoices, signed delivery notes, the contract and any credit control correspondence. The office-holder may accept, reduce or reject the proof. If they reduce or reject it, they must give reasons, and you’ve got 21 days to ask the court to look at it again.
If the directors disputed your invoice shortly before the insolvency, that dispute doesn’t by itself reduce your claim. The office-holder decides what to admit on the evidence you send. Where only part of the debt is disputed, claim the agreed amount and set out the disputed part separately with your reasons.
A proof also gives you a vote. In a creditors’ voluntary liquidation, creditors decide who the liquidator is and approve their fees. That’s usually done by post or online rather than at one of the old-style creditor meetings in liquidation.
I’d always lodge a proof, even when the dividend looks like nothing. It costs nothing, and it’s what gives you a say on the liquidator and their fees.
Liquidators set a last date for proving before each dividend, so send yours as soon as you have the paperwork together.
What Retention of Title and Set-Off Mean for Your Position
If you supplied goods on a retention of title clause, you keep ownership until you’re paid. Goods that are still identifiable at the debtor’s premises aren’t part of the insolvent estate, and you can reclaim them.
The clause must be part of your contract, and the goods must be traceable. Mixed, processed or resold stock usually defeats the claim. Clauses that claim the money from a resale usually fail too, because courts treat them as charges that needed registering.
Speed matters because the stock may not stay where you delivered it. Once goods are sold or mixed with other stock, they’re hard to trace. Contact the office-holder as soon as you hear of the appointment, with the contract and the delivery notes that identify your goods.
Administration works differently from liquidation here. While the company is in administration, a legal pause called a moratorium applies. You need the administrator’s consent or the court’s permission before you take goods back.
Set-off can also reduce your loss if you owe the company money too. That happens, for example, when you bought from it as well as sold to it. Under rule 14.25 of the Insolvency Rules, mutual debts with a company in liquidation are set off automatically.
You then prove only for the net figure. If you owe the company more than it owes you, you pay the difference to the liquidator.
Set-off doesn’t cover a debt that arose after you knew a liquidation was being sought or a winding-up petition was pending. Nor does it cover a debt you bought from someone else after the liquidation began. In an administration, set-off applies only once the administrator announces a payout to creditors.
We also ask every creditor whether they owe the company anything, because set-off can change the figure you should claim. Don’t pay a balance you owe after the insolvency until you’ve shown the set-off in your proof.
Timing, Dividends, and Realistic Recovery Expectations
There’s no fixed time limit for paying a dividend. The liquidator must send creditors a progress report each year, so you’ll know how the work is going and what has been recovered.
A dividend is hard to predict at the start. It depends mainly on whether the liquidator finds money beyond what the secured lender’s charge covers. Where a claim against the directors goes to court, the dividend usually waits for the result.
These recoveries can add to the money for unsecured creditors:
- an overdrawn director’s loan account, which the director owes back to the company;
- unlawful dividends, paid under the Companies Act 2006 when there weren’t enough profits to cover them;
- preferences under section 239 of the Insolvency Act 1986, where the company put one creditor in a better position;
- transactions at an undervalue under section 238, such as assets sold far below their worth;
- misfeasance claims under section 212, for a director’s breach of duty that cost the company money.
If the liquidator wins a claim against the directors, what’s left after the costs and higher-ranking creditors can reach unsecured creditors like you.
If the liquidator asks you for information, it’s worth answering fully. Your account of how the company traded with you in its last year can give them evidence they wouldn’t otherwise have.
When You Can Pursue Directors of an Insolvent Company Personally
The default rule under Salomon v A Salomon & Co Ltd [1897] AC 22 is that a limited company is a separate legal person. Its directors aren’t liable for its debts. There are exceptions, and they matter most when the company has nothing left.
The first is a personal guarantee. If a director signed one for your supply account, your claim against them survives the company’s insolvency.
You enforce it directly, through County Court proceedings or a bankruptcy petition against the guarantor. A bankruptcy petition needs a debt of at least £5,000 and carries a court fee and a deposit. Because the claim is against the director personally, the liquidation queue doesn’t apply to it.
The second is the liquidator’s own claims. They can bring misfeasance claims, preference and undervalue claims, and claims for wrongful trading. That means carrying on trading when the directors should have known insolvent liquidation couldn’t be avoided.
The liquidator usually brings these claims. A creditor can, however, bring a misfeasance claim or buy a claim from the liquidator.
The Supreme Court held in Sequana (2022) that directors must consider creditors’ interests once the company is insolvent or close to it. A liquidator can rely on that duty when reviewing the company’s last months.
The third is a dissolved company. If the debtor has been struck off without a liquidation, you can usually apply to the court to restore it within six years. A proper insolvency process can then run.
The Insolvency Service can also investigate and disqualify the directors, including directors of dissolved companies under a 2021 Act. A disqualification doesn’t repay your debt by itself. A disqualified director can, however, be ordered to pay compensation, and that money can go to the creditors who lost out.
Seeing the same directors trading again under a new name is hard to watch, but it isn’t automatically unlawful. Section 216 of the Insolvency Act 1986 limits it. Anyone who was a director in the 12 months before an insolvent liquidation can’t reuse its name for five years. The exceptions need the court’s permission or follow set rules.
A director who breaks that rule becomes personally liable for the new company’s debts. Our guide to phoenix companies explains when a business sold back to its directors is lawful and when it isn’t.
Your Next Step
If you’re an ordinary unsecured creditor, expect a low recovery. The steps that can still improve it, such as retention of title and set-off, need action in the first weeks after the appointment.
Work through them in this order. Confirm the insolvency on Companies House and the Gazette. Lodge a proof of debt with the supporting invoices. Claim any retention of title straight away. Show any set-off in your proof. Keep the paperwork for any personal guarantee a director gave you.
Claim VAT bad debt relief as soon as you’re entitled to it. I’d do that once the invoice is six months overdue, rather than waiting to see what the dividend brings.
Be wary of anyone who charges an upfront fee to recover a debt from a company that’s already in liquidation. A court claim won’t get you paid ahead of the other creditors, and lodging a proof costs nothing.
If someone offers to chase a liquidated company for a fee, I’d ask them what they can do that a free proof of debt can’t.
Take advice if your claim is above £10,000 or a director gave a personal guarantee. Do the same if you think the company paid others ahead of you in its last six months. A licensed insolvency practitioner can review the liquidator’s approach from your side as a creditor.
For most unsecured suppliers, the realistic outcome is a small dividend, if any, on a properly lodged proof of debt. More is possible where a director gave a guarantee or connected people were paid ahead of you. It’s also possible where the directors’ conduct gives the liquidator a claim.
Those routes depend on acting quickly. If you’re unsure which applies to you, talk it through with us.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens if I miss the liquidator’s claim deadline?
You can still lodge a proof of debt after the stated deadline. The liquidator doesn’t have to deal with it in time for the dividend being paid, and doesn’t have to reopen a dividend already paid.
Once your claim is admitted, though, you’re paid the dividend you missed out of the next funds, before other creditors receive a further dividend. If you’re late, write to the liquidator as soon as you realise.
Is it worth suing a company that is already in liquidation?
No. Once a winding-up order is made, section 130 of the Insolvency Act 1986 stops new court claims against the company without the court’s permission. In a creditors’ voluntary liquidation there’s no automatic stop, but the liquidator can ask the court for one.
A judgment would only rank as an unsecured claim anyway. Your remedy is the proof of debt, not a court claim against the company.
Can I claim VAT back on the bad debt?
Yes, under section 36 of the Value Added Tax Act 1994. You can reclaim the VAT once you’ve paid it to HMRC and the debt is six months overdue. You also need to write it off in your VAT records.
The six months run from the later of the payment due date and the date of supply. You must claim within four years and six months of that date. If a dividend arrives later, you repay the matching share of the VAT you reclaimed.
Do I need a solicitor to submit a Proof of Debt?
For a straightforward trade debt, no. The form is plain and the supporting documents are invoices you already hold. You normally bear the cost of proving your own debt, so a solicitor’s fee on a simple claim comes out of your own pocket.
A solicitor or a licensed insolvency practitioner adds value where the claim is disputed or involves a personal guarantee. The same goes for retention of title over mixed stock.
What does the prescribed part actually pay?
The prescribed part is money set aside for unsecured creditors from the assets covered by a floating charge. It’s 50% of the first £10,000 of that money and 20% of everything above it.
It’s capped at £800,000 on floating charges created on or after 6 April 2020, and £600,000 on older charges. In most liquidations it adds a modest amount, shared across all the unsecured creditors.
Could the liquidator claw back payments I already received?
Possibly. Suppose you were paid in the six months before the insolvency while others went unpaid. The liquidator can then review whether it was a preference under section 239.
For an unconnected supplier, the liquidator must show the company was insolvent and wanted to put you in a better position. That’s a high bar, set in Re M.C. Bacon Ltd. A payment made because you pressed for it on normal terms is unlikely to meet it.
How do I know if a personal guarantee is worth enforcing?
Check whether the director owns property, holds shares in other companies, or has assets you can see on a Land Registry search.
A guarantee against a director with no equity in a home and no other income tends to produce a bankruptcy and little cash. A guarantee against a director who owns a home outright is more likely to produce a payment.
Related Guides for Creditors of an Insolvent Company
- How to check if a company is insolvent: what a Companies House or Gazette result does and does not prove.
- What to do about customer insolvency: supply, credit and contract decisions while a customer is in trouble.
- Preferential and non-preferential creditors: the full order in which creditors are paid.
- Winding-up petitions: the route when the debtor is not yet in a formal procedure.






